{
  "entity": {
    "entity_id": "e_E1019DQAZKS",
    "name": "ChatDev",
    "slug": "chatdev",
    "entity_type": "repo",
    "homepage": "https://github.com/OpenBMB/ChatDev",
    "github_repo": "OpenBMB/ChatDev",
    "openalex_work_ids": [
      "W4402684050"
    ],
    "industry": "ai-agents",
    "sub_niche": "coding-agents",
    "cohort": "coding-agents",
    "axes": {
      "github_commit_velocity": {
        "slope": -0.005146063886757842,
        "cohort_z": 0.192,
        "recent_weekly_commits": 0.4,
        "stars_not_scored": 34741
      },
      "openalex_citation_momentum": {
        "status": "insufficient",
        "slope": null,
        "cohort_z": null,
        "total_citations": 714,
        "by_year": {
          "2024": 29,
          "2025": 183,
          "2026": 502
        },
        "proxy": null
      },
      "deps_direct_dependents_momentum": {
        "status": "out_of_panel",
        "slope": null,
        "theil_sen": null,
        "cohort_z": null,
        "latest": null,
        "points": null,
        "points_reconstructable": null,
        "as_of_partition": null,
        "unstable": null,
        "rising_vote": false
      }
    },
    "momentum": 52.4,
    "percentile": 58,
    "confidence": "low",
    "incumbent": false
  },
  "measurement_state": {
    "schema_version": "measurement_state_1",
    "entity_id": "e_E1019DQAZKS",
    "snapshot_date": "2026-11-14",
    "period": "2026-w46",
    "observation_availability": {
      "github_commit_velocity": "observed",
      "openalex_citation_momentum": "observed",
      "deps_direct_dependents_momentum": "source_not_measured"
    },
    "history_sufficiency": {
      "state": "sufficient",
      "weekly_observations": 19,
      "required": 4
    },
    "axis_coverage": {
      "axes": {
        "github_commit_velocity": "measurable",
        "openalex_citation_momentum": "insufficient_source_coverage",
        "deps_direct_dependents_momentum": "out_of_panel"
      },
      "coverage_reasons": {
        "github_commit_velocity": null,
        "openalex_citation_momentum": "source_returned_too_few",
        "deps_direct_dependents_momentum": null
      },
      "measurable_axes": [
        "github_commit_velocity"
      ],
      "measurable_axis_count": 1
    },
    "axes": {
      "github_commit_velocity": {
        "observation_availability": "observed",
        "history_sufficiency": {
          "state": "sufficient",
          "weekly_observations": 19,
          "required": 4
        },
        "axis_coverage": "measurable",
        "coverage_reason": null
      },
      "openalex_citation_momentum": {
        "observation_availability": "observed",
        "history_sufficiency": {
          "state": "sufficient",
          "weekly_observations": 19,
          "required": 4
        },
        "axis_coverage": "insufficient_source_coverage",
        "coverage_reason": "source_returned_too_few"
      },
      "deps_direct_dependents_momentum": {
        "observation_availability": "source_not_measured",
        "history_sufficiency": {
          "state": "insufficient",
          "weekly_observations": 0,
          "required": 14
        },
        "axis_coverage": "out_of_panel",
        "coverage_reason": null
      }
    },
    "gate_eligibility": {
      "state": "awaiting_axis_coverage",
      "evaluated_weekly": true
    },
    "positive_signal": {
      "state": "not_published",
      "label": null,
      "period": null
    },
    "phrases": {
      "history": "History: 19 weekly observations; minimum 4.",
      "development_axis": "Development velocity axis: measured.",
      "citation_axis": "Citation axis: insufficient source coverage (source returned too few observations).",
      "dependents_axis": "Direct-dependents axis: no admitted own package; not measured.",
      "axis_coverage": "Axis coverage: 1 of 3 axes measurable.",
      "gate": "Gate: not computable — 1 of 3 axes measurable",
      "signal": "Gate: not computable — 1 of 3 axes measurable",
      "compact": "1 of 3 axes measurable"
    }
  },
  "record_status": "measured",
  "observation": {
    "state": "measured",
    "latest_snapshot": "2026-11-14",
    "last_measured": "2026-11-14",
    "message": "Measured in snapshot 2026-11-14."
  },
  "dependent_readings": {
    "weekly": {
      "label": "Weekly direct dependents",
      "value": null,
      "date": null,
      "source": "https://evidaxis.org/snapshots/2026-11-14/snapshot.json",
      "role": "weekly_axis_input",
      "scoring_status": "out_of_panel",
      "package_scope": "admitted_own_package_union",
      "verification": "may_include_unverified",
      "definition": "deps.dev weekly direct dependents of the system's own packages. A package counts when it is declared in the system's own tree, published under that name and not attributed by deps.dev to another repository. Partition dates can repeat across snapshots. Package linkage is not uniformly verified: packages with no repository metadata (no_link) are unverified and remain admitted."
    },
    "daily": {
      "label": "Daily package dependents (unscored)",
      "value": null,
      "date": null,
      "period": null,
      "captured_at": null,
      "source": "",
      "role": "unscored_context",
      "package_scope": null,
      "verification": "not_measured",
      "definition": "deps.dev REST count for one identity-verified pinned package, captured daily and never scored. Its package scope differs from the weekly package union; neither value replaces the other."
    }
  },
  "events": [
    {
      "schema_version": "typed_feed_entry_1",
      "type": "observation",
      "event_kind": "measurement_activated",
      "title": "Weekly measurement activated: ChatDev",
      "summary": "Weekly measurement activated: ChatDev. Gate: not computable — history 1 of 4 weekly observations.",
      "snapshot_date": "2026-07-03",
      "period": "2026-w27",
      "date_published": "2026-07-03T08:48:34+00:00",
      "cohort": "coding-agents",
      "entity_ids": [
        "e_E1019DQAZKS"
      ],
      "source_fields": [
        "/entities/e_E1019DQAZKS"
      ],
      "state": {
        "schema_version": "measurement_state_1",
        "entity_id": "e_E1019DQAZKS",
        "snapshot_date": "2026-07-03",
        "period": "2026-w27",
        "observation_availability": {
          "github_commit_velocity": "observed",
          "openalex_citation_momentum": "observed"
        },
        "history_sufficiency": {
          "state": "insufficient",
          "weekly_observations": 1,
          "required": 4
        },
        "axis_coverage": {
          "axes": {
            "github_commit_velocity": "measurable",
            "openalex_citation_momentum": "insufficient_source_coverage"
          },
          "coverage_reasons": {
            "github_commit_velocity": null,
            "openalex_citation_momentum": "source_returned_too_few"
          },
          "measurable_axes": [
            "github_commit_velocity"
          ],
          "measurable_axis_count": 1
        },
        "axes": {
          "github_commit_velocity": {
            "observation_availability": "observed",
            "history_sufficiency": {
              "state": "insufficient",
              "weekly_observations": 1,
              "required": 4
            },
            "axis_coverage": "measurable",
            "coverage_reason": null
          },
          "openalex_citation_momentum": {
            "observation_availability": "observed",
            "history_sufficiency": {
              "state": "insufficient",
              "weekly_observations": 1,
              "required": 4
            },
            "axis_coverage": "insufficient_source_coverage",
            "coverage_reason": "source_returned_too_few"
          }
        },
        "gate_eligibility": {
          "state": "awaiting_observations",
          "evaluated_weekly": true
        },
        "positive_signal": {
          "state": "not_published",
          "label": null,
          "period": null
        },
        "phrases": {
          "history": "History: 1 of 4 weekly observations.",
          "development_axis": "Development velocity axis: measured.",
          "citation_axis": "Citation axis: insufficient source coverage (source returned too few observations).",
          "axis_coverage": "Axis coverage: 1 measurable axis.",
          "gate": "Gate: not computable — history 1 of 4 weekly observations",
          "signal": "Gate: not computable — history 1 of 4 weekly observations",
          "compact": "1 measurable axis"
        },
        "record_status": "measured"
      },
      "id": "observation-2026-w27-8d8ce9f77141f007",
      "url": "https://evidaxis.org/signals/observation-2026-w27-8d8ce9f77141f007/"
    },
    {
      "schema_version": "typed_feed_entry_1",
      "type": "observation",
      "event_kind": "history_sufficient",
      "title": "Four-week history recorded: ChatDev",
      "summary": "Four-week history recorded: ChatDev. Gate: not computable — 1 of 2 axes measurable (source returned too few observations).",
      "snapshot_date": "2026-07-25",
      "period": "2026-w30",
      "date_published": "2026-07-25T08:32:38+00:00",
      "cohort": "coding-agents",
      "entity_ids": [
        "e_E1019DQAZKS"
      ],
      "source_fields": [
        "/entities/e_E1019DQAZKS/history_sufficiency"
      ],
      "state": {
        "schema_version": "measurement_state_1",
        "entity_id": "e_E1019DQAZKS",
        "snapshot_date": "2026-07-25",
        "period": "2026-w30",
        "observation_availability": {
          "github_commit_velocity": "observed",
          "openalex_citation_momentum": "observed"
        },
        "history_sufficiency": {
          "state": "sufficient",
          "weekly_observations": 4,
          "required": 4
        },
        "axis_coverage": {
          "axes": {
            "github_commit_velocity": "measurable",
            "openalex_citation_momentum": "insufficient_source_coverage"
          },
          "coverage_reasons": {
            "github_commit_velocity": null,
            "openalex_citation_momentum": "source_returned_too_few"
          },
          "measurable_axes": [
            "github_commit_velocity"
          ],
          "measurable_axis_count": 1
        },
        "axes": {
          "github_commit_velocity": {
            "observation_availability": "observed",
            "history_sufficiency": {
              "state": "sufficient",
              "weekly_observations": 4,
              "required": 4
            },
            "axis_coverage": "measurable",
            "coverage_reason": null
          },
          "openalex_citation_momentum": {
            "observation_availability": "observed",
            "history_sufficiency": {
              "state": "sufficient",
              "weekly_observations": 4,
              "required": 4
            },
            "axis_coverage": "insufficient_source_coverage",
            "coverage_reason": "source_returned_too_few"
          }
        },
        "gate_eligibility": {
          "state": "awaiting_axis_coverage",
          "evaluated_weekly": true
        },
        "positive_signal": {
          "state": "not_published",
          "label": null,
          "period": null
        },
        "phrases": {
          "history": "History: 4 weekly observations; minimum 4.",
          "development_axis": "Development velocity axis: measured.",
          "citation_axis": "Citation axis: insufficient source coverage (source returned too few observations).",
          "axis_coverage": "Axis coverage: 1 measurable axis.",
          "gate": "Gate: not computable — 1 of 2 axes measurable (source returned too few observations)",
          "signal": "Gate: not computable — 1 of 2 axes measurable (source returned too few observations)",
          "compact": "1 measurable axis"
        },
        "record_status": "measured"
      },
      "id": "observation-2026-w30-5e40ae75e6e4e633",
      "url": "https://evidaxis.org/signals/observation-2026-w30-5e40ae75e6e4e633/"
    },
    {
      "schema_version": "typed_feed_entry_1",
      "type": "observation",
      "event_kind": "collection_failed",
      "title": "Collection record unavailable: ChatDev",
      "summary": "No observation record was produced for ChatDev in 2026-w34; collection state: failed.",
      "snapshot_date": "2026-08-22",
      "period": "2026-w34",
      "date_published": "2026-08-22T07:13:33+00:00",
      "cohort": "coding-agents",
      "entity_ids": [
        "e_E1019DQAZKS"
      ],
      "source_fields": [
        "/dropped/e_E1019DQAZKS"
      ],
      "state": {
        "record_status": "observation_skipped",
        "observation": {
          "state": "observation_skipped",
          "latest_snapshot": "2026-08-22",
          "last_measured": "2026-08-15",
          "message": "Not measured in this snapshot: the weekly collection produced no record for this system (a declared gap). Last measured 2026-08-15. The next attempt is the next weekly snapshot."
        }
      },
      "id": "observation-2026-w34-4f24d34400a4b52d",
      "url": "https://evidaxis.org/signals/observation-2026-w34-4f24d34400a4b52d/"
    },
    {
      "schema_version": "typed_feed_entry_1",
      "type": "observation",
      "event_kind": "measurement_resumed",
      "title": "Weekly measurement resumed: ChatDev",
      "summary": "Weekly measurement resumed: ChatDev. Gate: not computable — 1 of 2 axes measurable (source returned too few observations).",
      "snapshot_date": "2026-08-29",
      "period": "2026-w35",
      "date_published": "2026-08-29T12:49:44+00:00",
      "cohort": "coding-agents",
      "entity_ids": [
        "e_E1019DQAZKS"
      ],
      "source_fields": [
        "/entities/e_E1019DQAZKS"
      ],
      "state": {
        "schema_version": "measurement_state_1",
        "entity_id": "e_E1019DQAZKS",
        "snapshot_date": "2026-08-29",
        "period": "2026-w35",
        "observation_availability": {
          "github_commit_velocity": "observed",
          "openalex_citation_momentum": "observed"
        },
        "history_sufficiency": {
          "state": "sufficient",
          "weekly_observations": 8,
          "required": 4
        },
        "axis_coverage": {
          "axes": {
            "github_commit_velocity": "measurable",
            "openalex_citation_momentum": "insufficient_source_coverage"
          },
          "coverage_reasons": {
            "github_commit_velocity": null,
            "openalex_citation_momentum": "source_returned_too_few"
          },
          "measurable_axes": [
            "github_commit_velocity"
          ],
          "measurable_axis_count": 1
        },
        "axes": {
          "github_commit_velocity": {
            "observation_availability": "observed",
            "history_sufficiency": {
              "state": "sufficient",
              "weekly_observations": 8,
              "required": 4
            },
            "axis_coverage": "measurable",
            "coverage_reason": null
          },
          "openalex_citation_momentum": {
            "observation_availability": "observed",
            "history_sufficiency": {
              "state": "sufficient",
              "weekly_observations": 8,
              "required": 4
            },
            "axis_coverage": "insufficient_source_coverage",
            "coverage_reason": "source_returned_too_few"
          }
        },
        "gate_eligibility": {
          "state": "awaiting_axis_coverage",
          "evaluated_weekly": true
        },
        "positive_signal": {
          "state": "not_published",
          "label": null,
          "period": null
        },
        "phrases": {
          "history": "History: 8 weekly observations; minimum 4.",
          "development_axis": "Development velocity axis: measured.",
          "citation_axis": "Citation axis: insufficient source coverage (source returned too few observations).",
          "axis_coverage": "Axis coverage: 1 measurable axis.",
          "gate": "Gate: not computable — 1 of 2 axes measurable (source returned too few observations)",
          "signal": "Gate: not computable — 1 of 2 axes measurable (source returned too few observations)",
          "compact": "1 measurable axis"
        },
        "record_status": "measured"
      },
      "id": "observation-2026-w35-3f03c1cbfe25ad6c",
      "url": "https://evidaxis.org/signals/observation-2026-w35-3f03c1cbfe25ad6c/"
    }
  ],
  "last_seen_snapshot": "2026-11-14",
  "claim_urn": "urn:evidaxis:claim:e_E1019DQAZKS:m5:2026-11-14",
  "score_receipt": {
    "methodology_version": "m5",
    "snapshot_id": "04724603bccf",
    "snapshot_date": "2026-11-14",
    "period": "2026-w46",
    "source": "https://evidaxis.org/snapshots/2026-11-14/"
  },
  "license": "CC0-1.0",
  "canonical": "https://evidaxis.org/e/e_E1019DQAZKS/",
  "sameAs": [
    "https://github.com/OpenBMB/ChatDev",
    "https://openalex.org/W4402684050"
  ]
}